Betrayal of Judas

Written by:
Randy Tadros
Sameh Wanis
St. Mary Church
Atlanta, GA


Judas Iscariot, most famously known as the one who betrayed the Lord Jesus Christ, was a chosen Apostle of the Lord Jesus Christ. While all of the other Apostles where Galileans, Judas was a native of the city of Carioth in Judah. Among Judas' duties was carrying the purse for the disciples. As written by St. John, (John 12:4-6), the motives of Judas were evident from the beginning. King David prophesied his betrayal saying, “Even my own familiar friend in whom I trusted, who ate my bread, has lifted up his heel against me” (Psalm 41:9). The prophet David also prophesied the consequences of his actions and the pain veered to his children in Psalm 109:2-20. When the precious ointment was used to anoint the feet of the Lord Jesus Christ, Judas asked why the ointment was not sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor. His concern for the poor was not the issue, but rather the money, seeing that he was carrying the purse and the things put therein.

It’s worth highlighting certain characteristics and actions taken to accomplish betrayal. The conspiracy to arrest the Messiah started when Judas decided to approach the chief priests and Pharisees. It is mentioned that he was the one to approach the chief priests and not vice versa. In other words, Judas was not externally tempted to commit this sin, but rather prompted from within. Various theories have been discussed on the possible desires or motives that caused Judas to think and act the way he did. It should be noted that Judas’ consequent death was not a peaceful one. When Judas saw that the Lord Christ had been condenmed, he felt great remorse and returned the thirty pieces of silver and sought to hang himself in the potters field. Although Judas was remorseful, he was not repentent. As it is written, he jumped from the top of a tree in the attempt to break his neck, and in doing so he separated his midsection causing his entrails to gush out. We can draw an archetype between this inner gushing of organs to the origin of his sin being from within. But, Judas’ approach to remove the sin was one that led to his death. The field where this took place is, up to this day, called, “Akel-Dama”, field of blood. Note that the high priests refused to keep the returned money, but used the money to buy this field and bury the foreigners in town.

The various theories for Judas’ motives are many, only a few will be mentioned. Judas, like many other Jews at the time and like all Jews now, could have been waiting for a triumphant king to liberate Israel from Roman rule. He might have been desiring to gain a governmental position in the new Israel. As he learned more about the Lord Jesus and His mission of salvation, he started to lose hope in what he had been dreaming of ever since he took on his discipleship with the Lord Christ. Judas was expecting and seeking a savior for Israel and not for human kind.

Judas could have decided to join the high priests and Pharisees, which according to earthly expectations, was the "victorious" party. As previously mentioned, Judas was feeling let down by the Lord Jesus as He was not fighting for the liberation of Israel. Judas wanted more for his country than he did for his salvation.

A weaker argument is that Judas desired the 30 pieces of silver, which was at the time, the price of a slave. Ironically, the number 30 is a result of the product of 5 and 6. In the Holy Scripture 5 symbolizes the five senses of humanity used to interact with the surrounding environment. The number 6 is the number to denote Satan, being powerful, but short of the Supreme God, Whom is symbolized by 7. This product is the basic necessity of uniting the human and the evil to manifest an evil work. Contrast this to the simpler model of marriage where the two individuals ,1 and 1, unite to produce 1 by the product of their representative numbers 1 and 1. They are not added to produce 2.

Another possible theory is that Judas was not pleased at the public rebuke he received from his Master at the Last Supper. His feelings of alienation from his desire for a temporal position in an earthly kindgom could have led him to place the Lord Christ in a contraversial position to test Him with hopes of gaining insight on His mission. This was the time for Judas to see if the Lord Christ could flee the Roman soldiers and demonstrate power over the occupying Roman rule.

What does this great incident have to do with me? Regardless of what was really going on in Judas’ inner self, According to the Gnostics, this had to happen for our redemption. Should we then view Judas as a vital link in the process leading to our salvation, and as a result be thankful for him or was it to clarify the sharp contrast in Judas’ reaction to his sin versus that of St Peter’s in his famous denial of the Lord Christ?

In the end, Judas decided to end all hope of a new start and committed another sin of killing himself. Did he desire to end his life and get to the afterlife and meet with Christ one-on-one to remorsefully apologize for his great sin, as Origen hypothosized? The answer is unknown, but we know that Judas did not betray his Master seeking a fulfilment of prophesy. If he did so, that would mean that he believed this is the Saviour, and if so, why did he regret it afterwards? As Christians we condemn his acts but we are not in the place of judging where his destiny lies. We know for sure that while the Lord Christ was manifested to us in the form of the Son of Man, every action of the people around Him was done out of freewill. There was no action that took place in the duration of the Lord Christ's time on earth that was not out of freewill, otherwise we will not have a true salvation. As sin came into the world by free will so was it removed.

If Judas did not betray the Lord Jesus Christ, then most surely some other evil manifested in another human would commit this act. If no other human was willing to commit this act, then evil in this world could not be linked with humans. If that was the case, we would be already saved, and the incarnation of God and the death of His only begotten Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, the Messiah would not be needed for our salvation.